Home › Covered Calls › Covered Call vs Collar
Covered Call vs Collar vs Protective Put: Which Fits Your Wheel Shares?
Once a put gets assigned and you own 100 shares, you have three common ways to manage them: sell a covered call for income, buy a protective put for insurance, or do both at once, which is a collar. They look similar on paper but behave very differently when the stock moves. This guide puts all three on the same shares with the same numbers so you can see the trade-off.
The short answer
A covered call earns premium and caps your upside, but leaves the downside open. A protective put costs premium and caps your downside, but leaves the upside open. A collar sells the call and buys the put, so the call premium pays for some or all of the put. You end up with a capped gain and a capped loss and little income. Most Wheel traders sell plain covered calls most of the time and reach for a collar only when a specific risk makes the downside worth paying to limit.
The three positions side by side
| Covered call | Protective put | Collar | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legs | 100 shares + 1 short call | 100 shares + 1 long put | 100 shares + 1 short call + 1 long put |
| Premium | You collect it | You pay it | Roughly offsets; small credit or debit |
| Upside | Capped at the call strike | Open, minus the put cost | Capped at the call strike |
| Downside | Open below breakeven | Floored at the put strike | Floored at the put strike |
| Best when | You expect flat to mildly up and want income | You fear a big drop but want to keep upside | You fear a big drop and accept giving up income and upside |
| Fit with the Wheel | The normal second half of the cycle | Rare; expensive to keep buying | Occasional; around specific risks |
One example, three ways
Example numbers. You sold a $50 put for $1.50 and were assigned, so you own 100 shares with a cost basis of $48.50. The stock is at $50. For the next month you could:
- Covered call: sell the $53 call for $1.00 ($100 in).
- Protective put: buy the $46 put for $0.90 ($90 out).
- Collar: do both, for a net credit of $0.10 ($10 in).
Here is the result per 100 shares at expiration, measured from the $48.50 cost basis:
| Stock at expiration | Shares only | Covered call | Protective put | Collar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $40 (sharp drop) | −$850 | −$750 | −$340 | −$240 |
| $48.50 (back to basis) | $0 | +$100 | −$90 | +$10 |
| $55 (rally) | +$650 | +$550 (called away at $53) | +$560 | +$460 (called away at $53) |
The pattern is the whole story. The covered call wins in the flat case and gives up a little in both directions. The protective put keeps the rally but pays $90 every month for insurance that only matters in a crash. The collar has the smallest worst case, −$240, and the smallest income. Its best case is capped at $460.
The maximums work out like this. Covered call: max gain $550, breakeven $47.50, no floor. Protective put: max loss $340, no cap. Collar: max gain $460, max loss $240.
Why most Wheel traders stick with covered calls
The Wheel is an income strategy. You sell puts only on stocks you are happy to own, so a drop after assignment is a risk you accepted on purpose. Buying a put every month to insure those shares works against the income you are trying to collect. In the example, a monthly $46 put costs about as much as the call brings in, which turns a paying position into a break-even one. Over a year, that adds up to most of your premium.
That is also why strike selection and position size do most of the risk work in the Wheel. If one assignment could hurt you badly, the position is too big, and a collar is an expensive patch on that.
When a collar does make sense
- Before a known event. Earnings or a big ruling can gap a stock far below your strike overnight. A collar for just that expiration limits the damage. See the Wheel around earnings.
- After a big gain you want to lock in. If the shares ran well above your basis and you are not ready to sell, a collar protects most of the gain for a small cost.
- A position that grew too large. If one stock became a big share of your account, a collar buys time to trim it without taking the full hit in a sell-off.
- Volatile markets. In a sharp downtrend, a floor can matter more than the income. See the Wheel in a bear market.
How to set up a collar on Wheel shares
- Pick the call strike as you normally would, at or above your cost basis so being called away still locks in a profit. See selling covered calls below cost basis for why that matters.
- Pick the put strike at the loss you can live with. Further out of the money is cheaper but protects less.
- Use the same expiration for both legs to keep it simple, and enter them as one order if your broker allows it.
- Check the net: a small credit or near-zero cost is typical. If the put costs much more than the call brings in, the protection is expensive right now.
- At expiration, decide again. You do not have to keep buying puts every month once the risk has passed.
What about the put-selling phase?
Before assignment you hold cash, not shares, so a protective put on shares does not apply. The equivalent move is buying a lower-strike put against your short put. That caps your loss but turns the trade into a put credit spread, which is a different strategy with different math. Compare them in cash-secured put vs put credit spread.
Common mistakes
- Collaring every month by habit. Paying for protection all the time quietly erases most of your Wheel income.
- Setting the call below cost basis to pay for the put. That can lock in a loss if the shares are called away.
- Forgetting early assignment. The short call in a collar can still be assigned early, especially before an ex-dividend date. See ex-dividend early assignment.
- Ignoring taxes in a taxable account. Protective puts and some covered calls can affect holding-period rules. Read Wheel strategy taxes before collaring shares you have held a long time.
If you want the step-by-step version of these choices, Spin the Wheel, Cash the Checks covers managing assigned shares from the first covered call to getting called away.
FAQ
What is the difference between a covered call and a collar?
A covered call is owning 100 shares and selling one call against them for income. A collar adds a bought put below the stock price, so you trade some or all of the call premium for a floor under your losses.
Is a collar better than a covered call?
Neither is better in general. A covered call keeps more income but leaves all the downside below your breakeven. A collar gives up most of the income to cap the loss. It depends on whether protection or income matters more for that position right now.
What is the difference between a covered call and a protective put?
A covered call sells upside to collect premium. A protective put pays premium to buy downside insurance and keeps all the upside. One brings in money, the other costs money.
Can you use a protective put with the Wheel strategy?
Yes. After assignment you can buy a put under your shares while you sell covered calls, which turns the position into a collar. During the put-selling phase, buying a lower put against your short put turns it into a put credit spread.
What is a zero-cost collar?
A collar where the premium from the call you sell roughly pays for the put you buy. It costs little or nothing up front, but it caps your upside at the call strike and your income at about zero.